All Topics / Overseas Deals / Depreciation which country
If an Australian Discretionary trust buys an investment property in Nz which depreciation tables are used to work out depreciation.
1
Those of NZ or Australia?2
What about Vice-a-versa?There is no great benefit in buying New Zealand property in an Australian structure. If you wish to invest there you should establis a structure in New Zealand, and borrow the money there.
We have spent a great deal of time and money looking at the best structures for Australians to purchase in New Zealand.
To answer your qustion if you buy in an Australian structure your not in the New Zealand tax structure your in ours. You will get some costs but not all. My I decided to buy property for my clients and I in New Zealand the structure was by far the most important point
Nigel Kibel
http://www.propertyknowhow.com.au
Australian and New Zealand Buyers advocate
service and seminarsNigel Kibel | Property Know How
http://propertyknowhow.com.au
Email Me | Phone MeWe have just launched a new website join our membership today
Hi there,
I have owned NZ property in both structures.“To answer your qustion if you buy in an Australian structure your not in the New Zealand tax structure your in ours.”
Actually you would be in both systems then. The Australian Trust that owned property in NZ requires a full NZ tax return complying with NZ Tax Laws for a foreign trust. However the Trust then has to do an Australian return as well (one good reason not to have an NZ trust – save on tax returns!!) the Aussie Trust then distributes the income to its beneficiaries who pay tax at their personal income tax rates.
Both the Aussie and NZ structures were able to take out loans without difficulty.
The benefit of NZ complying Trust is that it can chose to hold the income in the trust and pay tax at Trust rates.
The Australian trust cant do that I am told.
So definitely a benefit to buying in NZ using NZ structures as nkibel has said (my information is based on my own experiences and my own accountants advice. You should check with your own advisors to be sure that what you do suits your circumstances)
Cheers
CDCheers
CD
CastleDreamer
http://www.nzpropertytogo.comGood point CD. The IRD treats undistributed trust income much more favourably than in oz. So in theory if you have truely cash positive properties you can leave the excess income within the structure without making distributions to the beneficiaries at home in OZ or wherever. The OZ tax office will smash undistributed trust income earned by aussie trusts encouraging distributions.
.
Good LuckIf NZ DISCRETIONARY TRUST bought an OZ property then
which depreciation tables applyIf I remain the appointer and have a NZ ????????, what is the term, then upon sale there is No CGT to pay assuming I am Australian…..right?
If you are a New Zealand citizen and you purchase a property in Australia it is my understanding that the Nz Government allows you to use there depreciation scheme, it does not work the other way around
Nigel Kibel
http://www.propertyknowhow.com.au
Australian and New Zealand Buyers advocate
service and seminarsNigel Kibel | Property Know How
http://propertyknowhow.com.au
Email Me | Phone MeWe have just launched a new website join our membership today
Bottom line is if you want to take advantage of NZ’s depreciation, and the potential to not get caught with CGT in Australia you need to set up a struture in NZ that will enable you to repatriate money in OZ.
It’s important to understand that according to the ATO any Australian entity or person making a capital gain anywhere in the world is subject to CGT whether or not the monies are repatriated in Oz.
The good news is there a structure that can achieve these goals but it took us 12 months and thousands of dollars to achieve it (and it doesn’t include an LAQC which is what every man and his dog goes on about).
Anyhow there’s a bit more about the different types of structures in our book, but your best bet is to get a really good accountant in NZ who will work with your Australian accountant to ensure the structures in both countries are talored to your needs.
Happy hunting!
Sigridhttp://www.kiwiproperty.biz
New book “The Guide to New Zealand Property Investing – Australian Edition”
Available at our web site along with other NZ Resources for Australian InvestorsSigrid and Tony who have written The guide to New Zealand investing have spend a great deal of time and money researching the best structures for Australians investing in New Zealand. I suggest you read the book and talk to them about the stuctures.
Nigel Kibel
http://www.propertyknowhow.com.au
Australian and New Zealand Buyers advocate
service and seminarsNigel Kibel | Property Know How
http://propertyknowhow.com.au
Email Me | Phone MeWe have just launched a new website join our membership today
I would add that there are a couple of qualified accountants here on the forum who have NZ experience, and would be good people to get taxation advice and structuring advice from. Read lots of books and ask lots of questions, but at the end of the day, make sure that you use the right people to gain advice from – and its worth paying to get that advice as Nigel and Sigrid admit!!! I know, i’ve been the recipient of bad advice from people I should not have gone to because they were not specialists at what I needed.
Cheers
CD
CastleDreamer
http://www.nzpropertytogo.comI would add that there are a couple of qualified accountants here on the forum who have NZ experience, and would be good people to get taxation advice and structuring advice from. Read lots of books and ask lots of questions, but at the end of the day, make sure that you use the right people to gain advice from – and its worth paying to get that advice as Nigel and Sigrid admit!!! I know, i’ve been the recipient of bad advice from people I should not have gone to because they were not specialists at what I needed.
Cheers
CD
CastleDreamer
http://www.nzpropertytogo.comhi samuri,
in addition to the comments above you could try “Successful Trust Management”by Ross Holmes. He is a solicitor that has published widely on the subject. Good luck with it all.
P.S That book has a fair bit of practical advice and examples so it may answers some of your questions. Then when you seek professional legal advice you will be on the same page as the solicitor and be ready to ask the right questions.
Good Luck
You must be logged in to reply to this topic. If you don't have an account, you can register here.