Forum Replies Created
@ The Freckle
Funny how no one actually commented this. This is the ULTIMATE investment strategy. RE is a side dish where you sink some money just to give you some diversification. This is in case if you take Diversification as the Insurance against your ignorance (W. Baffet).
Best is to invest what you are good at, not in RE, Gold, Shares, Land…
gmh454 wrote:Very simplistic sensationalist view. Property is flat and will stay so for a while. Although continual building and renovation is improving the average of the stock, real movement if any, in recent years has been minimal. Factor inflation into the mix and it may have gone backwards in many areas.The term bloodbath could apply to certain areas like the Gold Coast, but overall the market is flat and with employment still getting worse will continue to do so, until the economy improves.
Jordan Wirsz is not that neutral in his review. Been biased towards driving investment from AU to USA market where he is positioned. You can see direct interest in scaring AU investors.
But, beside this I agree with gmh454. Was watching market since 2001, since my involvement. From 2008/2009, inflation corrected we are moving backwards. Not much, but good 2-3% year. I now make offer 10% below listed and it's a accepted norm. Use to have to offer asking or above to get vendor to sign the contract, back in 2006.
Agree with JacM.
Wynnum in Brisbane have more potential than Redcliff in this respect. It's on the water, plenty of infrastructure for Brisbane Port going up and you got JOBs.
That article on Redcliff makes me think of Gold Cost. Not enough industry to support population wages growth, so weak RE.
Like in above post, crunch the numbers and see what comes out. My approach would be to see if I can improve cashflow. Another one is to dump some cash in to the loan (assuming P+I loan) to place you on the brake-even point. From there onwards it will just keep on improving.
I do not see Redcliff booming anytime soon. Anyone with money is looking at Brisbane, close to CBD. That with remote location drives investor away from already lean market.
Looking at the maps, Brisbane have some decades of growth until it will start to pressure Redcliff prices upwards by crossing the boundary. By itself, it will not go up. Not enough people and industry.
Interesting comment about US market.
I was watching Los Angeles area, lower part of it some 2 hours from city.
Over the last few years higher end properties have sank down a bit, but still fairly expensive. I was concentrating on 700K – 1.5Mil. I did not see any price crash in good areas near the water, same confirmed my a friend who live there.
As Tinim mention above, it's poor and low end suburbs that actually got hit bad.
In Australian on the other hand, particullary in Brisbane, waterfront houses sank down from 2Mil to 1.5Mil and still falling. Properties on the Brisbane River are not much better, some go with 20-25% discount from 2007-2009 prices.
Cheaper houses are little bit better, 10-15% discounts from market high are more common.
Capital city home values fall over consecutive years, down -3.8%in 2011 and -0.4% in 2012.
RP Data just released their end-of-year housing data for 2012 and it confirms what many already knew. 125bps over the last 12 months still hasn’t been enough to get traction under the market and as we roll into the “fiscally responsible” new year 2013 isn’t looking all that great either. The latest uptick in commodity prices should provide some support for national incomes, so that is a positive as long as it can last, but given what we’ve seen in the trend in credit since the GFC that may just result in further down payment of debt rather than increasing asset prices.
With governments across the country all hoping that housing construction will provide some economic support it’s going to be an interesting year for the housing market, but with immigration again on the rise and the RBA predicted to cut deeper they may still be some upside in 2013. For the bulls Sydney and Darwin are still looking good, for the bears there is everywhere else.
sanasar, based on your post I can see alot of academic education. You need to get out more, mix with agents, other investors and get a feel of the market. No book will teach you this. Do not get me wrong, I do read few as well
Basically, its like any other business, you try and see IF you can be good at it. Most will fail, very few will prosper.
From the question you are asking, I will conclude that you are better not to part with your hard saved $$$ just yet. Opportunities are out there, investors are purchasing. It's just that you need to know what are you looking for.
No property on the market is truly CF+, even when advertised so as 6-7% rental return. You are actually starting to brake even from over 8% (depending on prop type) when consider day-to-day expenses and property maintenance. You need to make it CF+, here comes the art.
Oh boy, a holy grain question.
From this point in time RE prices can:
– rise
– stagnate
– drop
Also, they can rise/drop by different amount as well as for different length of time.
Imagine number of possible outcomes? Now, multiply them by number of possible government interventions and major moves in world economy.
So, in real world any prediction are worth no more than amount you paid for them
My expectation, next 12 months – slow meltdown. Next 5 years, stagnation overall.
But my actions are more based on what I see now, now what I expect. I see the gain – I go for it.
Only my strategy is based on my expectations, meaning I buy for cashflow not CG (mid therm).
Nigel Kibel wrote:I think that in a down market also creates opportunities. I can see that a city like Brisbane is currently under valued.I do not like boom markets its a little like being on the set of the walking dead. People over pay because they are worried about missing out. In a market like this if the deal works then in the medium term you will make money
Well said, we purchased few IP's lately, it's defiantly improving from investor point of view.
Shopping around now is a pleasure, 10% discounts are a norm. We make offers with 20% discounts, some are been considered by owners.
My take on prices in Brisbane (CBD + 30 min radius) to trend down some more. Say 10-15% is very realistic figure, since you already can get this level of discounting.
Been to few inspection this weekend, agents look lonely at some of the places.
Well, I am actually on opposite side of the fence. We hire people, run manufacturing facility.
Since 2008 we lost turnover, dismissed 25% of our staff. Our competition went of business (bust), our clients take 2 years to pay 60 day account.
None the less, guys that work for us on $25-30/h carry new Iphones + Ipads + drive $30K+ cars. They also go on holidays and renovate houses. I think there is some degree of disconnect with reality and lack of observation.
The fact is, we are likely to see more pain. 4 days working weeks very well can be an option mid 2013. When I mention this to our staff they look suprised, walk away and continue the trend.
If economy nosedive anymore in next 24 months, I can see many people not been able to meet the financial obligations AKA look out for repo sales.
To add one more variable to the discussion, consider that since GFC 2008, the age group 55-65 are also same people that had to stay in businesses to continue working. This is due to sudden drop of revenue and evaporating retirement savings plan in some cases knows as (SUPER fund losses).
They are now have worked extra four years in business trying to recover and stay afloat. As Ummester mentioned, time is running out for them, and they will give up on various grounds with in next 5 years (mainly health and capacity).
They will not be able to sell the businesses for same $$$ as pre 2008, profitability have dropped. And a lot less people with cash to purchase.
They are the same guys that hold multiples of IP's in Australia. They are your 5% of people that own 3 or more IP's. They now will need cash to support established lifestyle and increasing health bill. Selling IP's will look attractive, when you know you got 10-20 years left.
As a summary, I see multiples of downward pressure factors. I also, do look for supporting factors, but they are hard to come by. Willing to help me to update my list of positive/price support factors?
Thinking only about Major Cities:
– Inflation will support pricing
– Population Increase will support pricing
– Time factor, will allow economy healing. Will support pricing
The open house inspections I done over the last few weeks starting to look like "Freckle" scenario.
Owners purchased in 2007 for $845K, trying to get $745K. Two couples on the open house.
Owners listed property for $400K, few months later still there listed $365K. We are the only visitors at open house.
Had 2 open houses at same time, 11am. Both agents been calling me at 11am insisting to see the property. I choose one, and it was lonely walk thru a nice house.
The trend is fascinating, as I use to get very unhappy agents on the phone by calling them Saturday/Sunday. How, they offer to come out and show me the property anytime?! Love the newly found customer service.
So, while RP Data show us 2% drop in values across Brisbane, vendors commonly discount well over 10%.
Market is bumpy, some properties go under contract in in matter of one-two weeks. Other hang around for ages and discount a lot. High end properties are now sold with large discounts. $1M plus houses in Ascot coming up for sale weekly, some are 'special' in the way that been done up very nicely and have not seen market for a long time.
My take of the future if current trend continue: Slow meltdown of RE over the 5-7 years.
^
Good advice right there.
Sidenote, last inspections I made in Brisbane (last 4 weeks) looked sad. Agents look very lonely inside the big house. None is coming to have a look.
Interestingly, 8 weeks ago, 50% of properties we made offer, already had offers.
Market goes hot/cold in matter of weeks. First questions Agents now asking: Where do you stand financially (meaning do you have money)? Contract fail on finance clouse?
Oh boy, this is an OLD thread.
Let's throw some fun article in. Source
Slump looms as a third of new home sales abandoned
Melbourne's outer-suburban property market is facing a serious slump as distressed buyers and builders cancel one in every three new home purchases.
The collapse in sales could have serious repercussions for the state economy and the building industry, which employs more than 250,000 Victorians.
"We've never seen this before, so it's a very strong signal that the fundamentals are wrong," said Colin Keane, director of analyst group Research4, who compiled the new research.
<moderator: have deleted pasted text as it was too long. Please see article as linked above. Thanks>
OK, let's look at it from other side:
Say in Australia, if nothing dramatic happens and economy continue it's trajectory. As time moves forward, people/businesses gradually reduce debt (we are according to statistics already doing it in private sector). Government to reduce spending to match income, as already starting to happen. I cannot see why such a scenario not going to allow a country's economy to re-balance itself over time (say 10 years). I know the risk of deflation is there due to everyone reducing expenditure.
I have noted, that disregarding low nominal inflation and turbulent times since GFC, government still regularly rises minimum award wage. Almost ordering the economy to maintain some level of inflation. That coupled with relatively high by international standards interest rates, seem to run economy at constant inflation.
There are few ways out actually. Most known is German Style (1946) aka hyperinflation. You can have controlled inflation and just let the time do the job.
Just thinking here, state is no different to private individual. How many ppl do you know that have debt 400% yearly wages?
I know many who is at 800% of non business related debt! No one is going bust, only few.
From the start of GFC, almost 5 years have passed. 5 at say 3% inflation, we devaluate the debt already by some 12%?
Not trying to say I am right, just wanting to hear some opinions outside the box.
Now, if governments will manage to to keep economy from going in to the recession, how many years it will take to clear/devalue/inflate our way out of this?
I am thinking: are we up for some years of stagnation? Surely, further growth can only be sustained if debt levels significantly reduced.
bardon wrote:simple wrote:A lot of dancing there, but we are not going anywhere!
So are you saying that there wont be a property bust and that there isn't worse to come?
There is definitely no crash happening here. Some pain out there, but no bust.
It's 8 years in to this thread, prices still where we was in 2006. Went up/down and sideways now. Starting to look like there will be no 'bust', just a prolonged stagnation instead?!
Disregarding my view on what it will do, I am active investor, with last IP purchased in 2011. Current situation created some nice opportunities out there.
Commercial buildings like hotels have water chillers on the roof. They call them Cooling Towers. Much more energy efficient, but consume water and require some advanced water chemistry control due to recycling water flowing in the machine.
They do not work in humid environments when humidity is high and evaporation do not take place.
It's nice when you can do that. Some time you can get a steal. Not many are around.