Forum Replies Created
- ErikH wrote:Well… Rudd does speak fluent Mandarin, doesn't he?
Back onto topic, I found the following article on housing prices quite interesting: http://www.realestate.com.au/doc/review/july08/housing-prices.htm
Thanks , very interesting reading. It's nothing new but it's the first time banks agree that the housing market is overvalued. I posted this on GPHC.
Since you took your time to write such a nice post, I will reply inline.
harb wrote:Make sure you move to Sydney then. They have some of the most relaxed people in the country because of the relaxation techniques training they do on a daily base, on the way to work and back . The current trends is toward 4 hrs/ day of relaxation and properties as far away from the beach as possible are favored. Something to do with global warming, I think, because the other side of Lithgow seems to be fast becoming a favorite with Sydney workers.Do you think I am an idiot ? I'm an immigrant, just like you are ( unless you're an aboriginal ) but that doesn't mean I am stupid. I do my research on where to live, and Sydney is not on the list. That might change if houseprices drop and I have experienced the people. It might also not change, I'll see about that when I arrive in Australia. My dog needs quarantaine for a month, so I'll have a whole month to experience Sydney as it is. Furthermore, I have acquaintances who live in Sydney and can give me an impression of the city. The city is so big that there's bound to be good AND bad things in there. I'd be amazed to see only positives in Australia. Actually I don't expect Australia to be any better than The Netherlands. We need a change in life, and that's one thing that is sure to happen over in Australia : many things will be different ( take the weather for instance ).
harb wrote:You shouldn't have any problem finding lots of properties below cost near CBD and the beaches, up to 50% below market price in some cases.I would not be surprised to see this happening. 50% off the current prices would certainly be 'normal'. Prices as they are now are unsustainable in Australia. There is no way house prices will NOT drop. They have, in real terms in Sydney already dropped 30% , I'm sure you already knew this ? Anyway, still at least 30% more to go, up to 50% in some cases I'm sure. Sydney is the world's most unaffordable city. And from what I heard, people in Sydney aren't earning what people in Los Angeles ( Hollywood ? ) earn. It's unsustainable.
harb wrote:You are more likely to arrive here and find that most aussie IT jobs are outsourced to India and the pay is crap.Been there, done that. It's just a matter of time before the jobs come back. I've seen it happen in USA , Europe, and soon in Australia too. I might even specialize into 'post-outsourcing' drama consultancy. It's good business. Many businesses lost a lot of money on outsourcing stuff they shouldn't have, and have trouble getting that business back and integrated again. I've seen it all happen before. Australia is just a bit of a slow learner, that's all : And I can profit from that.
harb wrote:If you 're looking to buy a place you'll have to compete with a dump truck operator, welder or cleaner working on some mine site in FNQ or NW of WA. He'll make 3-4 times your salary and if that's not enough competition you'll also have investors from Asia who are able to buy with cash, outbid you and hold for the long term.Hm.. I seriously doubt anyone can outbid us to be honest. And why would I compete with those people ?
There's 50 times more houses for sale than there's buyers, didn't you know ?
If you were an asian investor, would you buy an overpriced, badly maintained house for 400.000AUD$ in a bad area with crap public transport in Australia, or would you buy 3 *NEW* houses for the same price in a good suburb in USA ? Really you clearly need to learn some investment basics. Who do you think is selling all those houses in Australia in an attempt to move out and get into USA property ?harb wrote:Then your choice will be to buy an "overpriced" property yourself or rent one from the cleaner or investor who outbid you in the first place. If only they could read your warnings about the CRASHING property market. Then while you are waiting for that 40% drop he'll be collecting half your income in rent and use it to pay off the property and even buy another one. After a year or two you'll probably get fat up with waiting for a crashWell.. there's the thing you see. He could be collecting half of my income. In which case I would still have half of my income to spend on living a nice life. I can also buy something and spend my WHOLE income on repayments. On top of this, the houseprices aren't going up for the next 3 years at least. At best, and this is utopia situation sketching, the houseprices will keep up with CPI ( and thus not get worth more in real terms ).
At worst, they will lose 80% of their value like in the USA. Let's get somewhere in the middle, and realistically speaking they will lose 40% of their value in 2-3 years. Why would I spend 2-3 years paying my whole income on something that loses SO much value, when I can rent for 2-3 years and then PAY CASH from what I earned in those 2-3 years ? Don't answer that, it was a rethorical question.harb wrote:, have enough of the nice weather with forty degrees plus, the beaches you were to busy working to enjoy, the nice people who are foaming at the mouth during a road rage attack and you'll miss your family and friends from back home. If your gf hasn't already left you by then you'll pack up your things and return to Holland wishing you never heard of Australia or Google Earth.I would be too busy to enjoy the beaches if I had to work overtime to keep up my mortgage repayments.
I'd rather rent and keep half my income to live my life. You only live once, and the premium of house ownership don't sound that appealing in a crashing market. I can invest my money in other things and earn more than I would earn by owning 20 houses.. so why own 20 houses and have the crap of tenants and stress, if I can easily earn the same or more by investing my money otherwise ? ( rethorical )harb wrote:But don't give up your dream Scamp, we need more cashed up people coming here to buy or rent. It stops the property market from crashing, pushes property prices higher and keeps the recession away.
[/quoteIt doesn't stop the property market from crashing. Just look at Los Angeles and UK who have a HUGE housing shortage compared to Australia, do you see their house prices going up because of immigration or their housing shortage ?… ( rethorical ).
I'd gladly rent and have everything taken care of. I could also just buy something if the right place comes up for the right price. I have seen some nice properties that are just a little overvalued, I'd gladly pay that with cash and get 20% or 30% rebate + FHOG + no taxes. Or I might go and have some fun at auctions. Who knows.
One thing is sure, I will enjoy the changes in my life that Australia will give me. I hope you enjoy your life too Harb.
just visit GPHC for a complete analysis and all the info you need.
Will there be a boom ? Ofcourse there will be.
When ? maybe in 10 years… maybe in 20 years…. who knows.Will there be a boom in the next 3 years ?
hahahahaha(h)Surprise surprise : Interest rates didn't move down.
harb wrote:Scamp wrote:The bottom could be anywhere between 3 years from now, or 20 years from now, depending on how much the government will mess with the whole thing. If the government does things like USA, then Australia is in for a 10 year long depression at least. At that point, the only thing that could potentially extinguish the fire is a massive world war.If you truly believe that why bother migrating to AU , wouldn't you be better off staying at home with mum & dad ?
Ofcourse not. Australia is a real nice country. Recessions will be everywhere, also in Europe, but they affect mostly people with debts, which we don't have and don't plan to have. Surely, we will lose some cash, who cares, we will build it up again after the recession. The whole point for us to move to Australia is to enjoy the nice weather, the beaches and the relaxed attitude of people.
bah I can't edit my post. September 2008 ofcourse…
the bottom is hard to predict, but the start of it is quite easy.
All the fundamentals have been laid around Australia. Now, all is needed is a lighter to light up the fuel.
That is coming in September 2009. Yep.. only 1 month leftMind you, it might take a while to light this incredible pile of crap. It could take 6 months before it's completely on fire. So you can safely say the start is September 2008 ( although January 2008 could also be named for putting down the basics in place ) but the real panic will occur later, when unemployment rises, and people start defaulting on their mortgages AND RENTS en masse. Then the fire will be lit. The bottom could be anywhere between 3 years from now, or 20 years from now, depending on how much the government will mess with the whole thing. If the government does things like USA, then Australia is in for a 10 year long depression at least. At that point, the only thing that could potentially extinguish the fire is a massive world war.
crashy wrote:Will Australia in 100 yrs be like Saudi Arabia is now?You mean, controlled by the USA ? In 100 years there won't be a USA anymore. But, there's clear signs that China will control Australia. They are spending all their USA worthless dollars on Australian assets now. I can see the Chinese reign over Australia's resources some day.
The RBA looks at underlying inflation – which strips out volatile price movements – when it comes to making decisions on interest rates. Underlying inflation was in line with expectations, growing 4.4 per cent for the year ended June, up from 4.25 per cent for the March year.
The last time inflation was this high was September 1991.
The RBA has a target of keeping inflation within a 2-3 per cent growth band
the joys of property ownership. What do you expect ? To get renters that take care of the house like you would ?
Dreams… Anyway, soon the rental market will crash also, so your situation isn't the worst. The worst is when you can't find renters at all.Thanks for explaining wireless. Yes that's the main reason : speculation.
Anyway, just like with oil, there is NO SHORTAGE OF AUSTRALIAN HOUSES.
In fact, there are 900.000 EMPTY HOUSES in australia.
And.. how do you explain the massive amount of houses for sale ? If there was a real shortage, surely these would have been bought.
The only 'shortage' there is in Australia is one of luxury. Not having to drive 2 hours to work every day, not having to live next to criminals, not having to walk 800 long meters to the beach. Yes, we all want a McMansion on the beaches.
"oooh.. gee Bondi Beach is really crowded… it really sucks to own a house on this busy beach".The fact that there aren't 1 million Ferrari's in Australia doesn't mean there's a shortage of Ferrari's.
It's just means people can't afford them…. that's all. Same with houses.I won't discuss the housing shortage anymore : There is NO housing shortage. I have done the research, and there are 900.000 EMPTY HOUSES. EMPTY… NOT USED… 900.000 !!…
And what do you think will happen when the dollar sinks ?…
Paul22M wrote:I reckon we bring Scamp over to Australia and make him head of the RBA, or even prime ministerWho would want to be prime minister in Australia ? It's like wanting to be the president of the USA.
Anyway, first thing any REAL prime minister does is cut the tax benefits on property investment as a whole.
I know, it's been tried before, but the chickens reverted it. Bad choice, look at what's coming now.About political pressure, I quote Rudd : "I will fight inflation AT ALL COSTS"
There's rampant inflation. So what do you think he will do ? What do you think he CAN do ?
No no.. this is one of those recessions that Australia just needs to have.Stay at home , sit out the storm and get free food and laundry.
Don't join the game now. In 2-3 years you can consider buying.
Why do you think the market is collapsing ?… because no FHB can afford a home.
Can you afford one ? No… Join the ranks, just sit ou the storm and if you get desperate about living away from your parents go on holiday in Thailand for 2 years, it'll be a LOAD cheaper than to buy a home now.longterminvestor wrote:ScampLost a lot of credibility with your most recent statements.
No one can make a reasonable assessment of whether RBA will decrease rates or not as they do tend to make mistakes and bow to political pressure. US a third world country? – US minimum wage is $6 per hour, they have a very low currency, they are recognising their problems, the bank deposits are insured to $100,000 per depositor and the Role of any Federal Reserve is to ensure the stability of the financial system. I feel the US will fix their problems eventually and return to be an ever stronger powerhouse, but not without considerable pain from those who borrowed too much – they will all be wiped out.
The RBA should not have decreased rates in 2002 – 03 but they did. Now look at the problems.
Anyway, high interest rates put pressure on the housing markets and resetting loans deepen the problem..But it is losing jobs and rising unemployment that finishes the job. Higher interest rates slows the economy, increases borrowing costs for companies and individuals, company profits deteriorate, companies cut costs and sack people. Unemployment rises. This is the economic cycle or clock. A country needs to have a recession every 5 years or so on average to keep it healthy and stop unrealistic expectations from developing.
Australias problem is we have been living in a perfect world for 15 years and we do not think a recession is a normal part of the economic cycle. We have tried to rewrite the economic text books (because it is different now.)
It is not different now!
Whether the RBA bows to political pressure and reduces interest rates or not will not stop the property market from crashing as people have taken on too much debt and now people are going to lose their jobs and not be able to service their debt. The damage has already been done.
It is not rising interest rates that crash property markets, it is rising unemployment after massive expolsion in debt and after massive price gains.
Australia is squeezed between a rock and a hard place.
Any reduction in interest rates will cause the $A to fall and this will cause imported inflation from all the imports we are sucking in. We have stagflation. Slowing economic growth and rising cost push inflation. The oil price will fall, but the falling $A will negate this effect and put upward pressure on petrol prices.
Rock and a hard place. – Now the pain must happen to correct our excesses of the past.
There are only 3 ways debt disappears – paid back – taken back – or bankruptcy.
You just typed over exactly what I said already a long time ago. What's new ?
RBA will *NOT* lower the rates, how many times do you want me to tell you.
Just take the advice, and do something with it. It can be predicted, and it just was.
Just do the maths and you will know why they won't lower the rates.howardcm wrote:What would you do if you were in my position?I have a $50k deposit and earn $50k + Super a year and am 21 years old
I qualify for the Keystart homeloan where they put in 30% of total price of the home with no interest and you can buy the 30% back at your own leisure. I put in the 50K and borrow the rest. With the Keystart loan I can purchase a property up to $360k
In 6 months time I will get a guaranteed payrise taking me over the maximum wage for the Keystart home loan thus forcing me to loan out the full amount for the house minus my deposit.
So buy between now and 6 months time and only have to purchase 70% of the house
Or wait for the so called property fall and buy then?
Tell your boss to wait with the payrise and give you a bonus at the end of next year instead ( just have him sign it on paper to be sure ). That solves your problem. There's no reason to buy anything now. One after the other, the major building companies are falling, and their land banks will be dumped on the market. That means more and cheaper land, which means cheaper houses. Houseprices won't rise for at least the next year ( probably they won't rise in the next 10 years from now , in real terms , so they will rise max 5% which is CPI ).
Mister : I have no idea on stocks. Most of the stocks seem to be going downwards. If you feel like a gamble , you can put a short on Manpower or on some building companies. But remember : This is a big gamble. I'm not much of a gambler myself, so I invest in gold instead.
Why will gold price go up ? Because Australia has been printing record amounts of money the last few years, which means there's more money than gold, which will push gold prices up. Well, that's how I think about it anyway. Gold also is a safe haven for people who don't want to take too many risks in a recession. Usually wars and recessions push goldprices up. With a global recession, a lot of people will start buying gold.
But remember that gold is at an all time high price now. Even though, I still think it will go up.
I actually have an outstanding bet with someone on this forum that gold would cost 1200US$ by March 2009.it's about 900US$ now : http://www.goldprice.net/gold_price_links.php
mpertile wrote:And the price of oil (and petrol) is so high, why? Because there's a shortage on the world market…Wrong. There's plenty of oil. Speculation drove oil prices up , not 'shortage'. Basically, the exact same thing that happened to housing. Speculation drove those prices up also, not shortage. There's no shortage of housing in Australia. There's no shortage of oil in the world.
Anyway, RBA will not lower interest rates upcoming week : Keep dreaming.
Just go to the council and explain your situation. You probably will have to pay only for 1 subdivision if you make sure that your dudes do all the work in 1 go, instead of doing it in 2-3 times. So make sure you have the whole situation sketched up , not just half the story that you have here. ( I presume 2 blocks of 400 and 1 block of 300 ) That's just 1 subdivision with minor extra costs for the extra realignment.
harb wrote:Scamp wrote:http://www.news.com.au/business/money/story/0,25479,24105428-5013951,00.htmlon news.com.au :
THE weakest market in four years has seen house prices drop in most capitals with predictions next year could see 10 per cent falls.
You forgot this part "Weak market blamed on high interest rates"
on news.com.au today :
"For starters, prepare for official interest rate cuts now. The Reserve Bank wants to cut next week. It will cut next month. "
http://www.news.com.au/business/money/story/0,25479,24111198-5016110,00.html
If the rates eventually come down, lets say 2% over the next year, do you think the rents will also come down by a similar $ amount ? Or do you think investors will return and if so what would that do to house prices ?
A lot of blabla. The housing crash isn't a result of the high interest rates, it's a result of the house prices.
Interest cuts will make Australia's pain worse rather than easier. It will just make a recession more painful, that's really all it does. RBA will not cut rates this year, and banks will keep raising interest rates.
Anything else will rise unemployment, hurt export and not have an effect anyway. There you have it : the truth. No good news coming for some years unfortunately.puffl wrote:Scamp wrote:[
Banks will keep raising interestrates because credit is expensive. What RBA does is futile.That doesn't answer my question. Nor does pointing to yesterday's APM figures.
What I'm asking is why you think the RBA should increase interest rates even though, as you say, there's a recession coming.
In saying that you believe a recession is coming and that the RBA should increase interest rates, you're either arguing that the RBA should purposefully deepen the recession (I don't think many Australians would agree with you), or you're exposing your lack of economic understanding.
Which is it?
A recession is not a bad thing. It's just a shift in wealth, a 'season of economic times' as you wish. Recessions are a natural phenomenon. RBA should increase interest rates to counter rampant inflation. RBA exists to make the inflation <-> recession less painful. Their main role NOW is to counter inflation. We all know that recession is coming, there's no stopping that. It's global now. But why would they allow inflation to go up 10% p.a. , and THEN allow a recession ? That will hurt people more than if you fight inflation now.
The RBA will not deepen the recession, they will shorten it, if they fight inflation. Let me put it simply, which would you rather have :
1) you get unemployed and food costs 100$ per week ( RBA rises interest now )
2) you get unemployed and food costs 200$ per week ( RBA lowers interest now )