Forum Replies Created

Viewing 16 posts - 21 through 36 (of 36 total)
  • Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    scrap that last comment – i just realised i'd be paying non-deductible interest on $40K either way! 

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    I was also just doing some further calcs was thinking…

    even though we will pay $2000 more LMI if we keep the first loan at 80% LVR and have the second at 90%, when or if we eventually move into the 2nd IP and make it our PPOR, the interest on the LOC we used for the deposit is no longer tax deductible and therefore we would be only paying $1960/year ($28,000 LOC at 7% interest) compared to $4760/yr ($68,000 LOC) if used the extra 10%….

    hmmm so much to think about! Am i over analysing it!!?? 

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Richard, what do you mean when you said:

    "If you stay with the 1 lender and amount is over $500K"

    we are planning to have the 2 loans with the same lender which would make our total borrowings appx $730K.
    will this increase the LMI??

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Ok, i'm aiming for the buy and hold strategy too so thats why i'm looking at this prop – it is 10Km from the brisbane CBD so i think we will get some good cap growth out of it in years to come – not to mention a good rental yield.

    So we went to an inspection today for a unit in our current IP's building complex, asking for offers over $415K (it is exactly the same layout except for a small balcony off the 2nd bedroom) and other units have sold this year for $400K and $405K. So i'm hoping the bank will value our IP at $400K. So…

    Our current loan amount is $292K.  So if we increased our current loan to 90% LVR (i know this may be risky but its easily servicable) using LOC we would have 68K to put towards the new loan and pay $5,580 LMI.

    Then, together with our deposit of $30K, we will have $98K to put toward a $440K property

    So borrowing $456K (inc costs)
    Less $98K
    Brings the total loan amount to $358K, + $2200 LMI (81% LVR)

    So in the end, we'll have one loan at 90% LVR and the other at 81% LVR with total LMI payable $7780.

    Does anyone see any issues with this scenario??

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Ok, I understand what your saying S/C – clever thinking. i really appreciate your time and energy helping me out!
    So theoretically, it doesnt really matter if we buy now or buy in 3 years time – the main difference is that the whole process will be less risky if we wait. But thats looking purely at loan amount…

    The main driving force of buying another IP now is that we want to secure ourselves a house in Brisbane near the parentals that we may eventually live in when/if we move back up that way. This means we would like a comfortable 3 bdr house. In 3 years time, even though we can borrow 456K at 80% LVR, the actual type of property we could get for that amount will probably be a lot smaller and older. Then our problem will be affording $3000/mth P&I repayments…. then again, if we really get stuck, we can always sell the first IP to reduce the PPOR loan…
    hmmmm, so much to think about.

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    oh ok, so if thats the case Richard, and we get a separate loan, will we still be able to borrow that amount or will it reduce our borrowing power?

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Thanks StumpCam,

    so do you feel the same way about not not using a LOC and just paying the LMI in order to get into the market sooner? ie keep appx 75% LVR on first IP and 96% LVR (inc LMI) (93% pre LMI) on second IP?

    The after tax figures look pretty good though even inc $24,000 LMI- appx $8000/yr which we can afford.

    So in this case, wouldnt it be better to use the LMI to get in sooner and gain capital growth rather than wait 3-4yrs to save for a deposit (after which the value of BOTH props would have gained appx $70K each calculated on an average rate of 5%?

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    yeah that makes sense. Thanks for the advice Terry!  

    just another annoying question

    would use suggest choosing a variable rate loan with an offset account over a fixed rate without an offset for a PPOR mortgage? i suppose it would depend on the amount of extra funds we plan to put into the account opposed to the extra interest we will be charged if rate increase…. oh the decisions!

    Cheers,

    Kyla

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    ok, i think i understand.

    Our first IP has an IO loan with an offset account which we have been putting all our savings into – so we're on the right track there

    Our next IP will most likely be a IO fixed rate mortgage (most likely without an offset account since these are rare).

    i will definetly look into setting up a LOC with the first IP's mortgage – thanks for that tip! by the way – in what way do your tax deductions increase if you use LOC if interest stays the same?

    Kyla

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Hi Terry,

    I have considered that as well but how will we go about using the equity to reduce the amount of the mortgage? is that what re-financing is for? sorry, im a bit of a newbie!

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    I just had another lightbulb moment-

    i keep reading about trusts:
    could we establish a trust, borrow money in the trusts name to buy the IP from us and then put the profit towards the PPOR?would this suit our situation?

    Would we have to buy the property in certain names?

    cheers!

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Ok thanks guys, i thought so!

    She is also considering building a 'live-in garage/granny flat' in the back yard with it own street entry to rent out.

    1. am i correct in saying that the interest on the money she borrows to build the flat will be tax deductible because its an investment?

    2. she also thought about subdividing the the property in order to have its own electricity and water supply however it was apparently going to cost 60k to get approved before the costs of connecting separate power and water supplies. What are your thoughts on this plan?

    Cheers!

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Yes, the NSW office of state revenue can confirm that if you email them.

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    Thanks everyone! I think we will end up having to put the funds in a term deposit account. We should probably hit the book shops this weekend too! Actually imugli, i made some enquiries with the NSW office of state revenue before we purchased the unit and apparently, if we never reside in the investment property, we are still eligible for the FHOG when it comes time to purchase our PPOR… i was pretty surprised to hear that actually, i dont think many people realise it. ;-)

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    thanks for all your comments and advice!
    Im new at this so my knowledge is fairly basic! i guess our plan and strategy was to get into the property market while it was a good time to buy as well as reduce our taxable income (my husband is in the 40% margin and im in the 30%). We ended up buying a unit instead of waiting until we could afford to by a place suitable to actually live in, in the same area. So now our aim is to buy a PPOR in 3 years time (at the earliest).

    Initially we were planning to make extra repayments inorder to build equity so the loan for our PPOR won't be as big. But then i thought we could redraw the extra repayments and use that as a deposit. However now i realise thats not a viable option. So should we still try to build equity or put it into a term deposit account?

    Profile photo of KRH83KRH83
    Participant
    @krh83
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 47

    thanks Imugli,
    I realise now that we should have chosen a loan with the option of an off set account but unfortunetly it doesnt come with the fixed rate loan so until it changes to a variable rate in 2 years time, what should we do with the extra funds?? I also realise that we should have gone with a variable rate from the start too! Hind sight is a wonderful thing!!

Viewing 16 posts - 21 through 36 (of 36 total)