Forum Replies Created
Hi Dom,
Some suggestions;
1. Don’t sell them all in the same financial year.
2. If appropriate balance the gains with other losses elsewhere.
3. Sell in a low/no income year.Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Jars,
Another thought – the holiday property almost doubles your debt level but yet only contributes around 25% of your total rental income.
Seems to me it will be a long term drain – having said that maybe some well located in good growth areas that add proportionately more to your total rental income may be a better option than pure cashflow buys.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Originally posted by 1HotValuer:Kay,
we use very expensive paper.Love the sense of humour[biggrin]
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Gataga,
I’m curious, why you are considering this move?
I notice you have $35K available to you.
It seems to me that, provided you qualify, and meet FHOG guidelines you would be better off buying your own property in your own name.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi SIS,
The wife and I have spent most of our time in rental accommodation – work related so not by choice.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Mydral,
As the property used to be your PPOR (and assuming you don’t have a new PPOR) then you will have a 6 year exemption before any CGT kicks in.
If however you bought another place to live then any CG will be apportioned over the period of ownership. Eg 75% of the time the property was your PPOR then 75% of the gain is exempt from tax.
It would seem the property is going to cost you between $540 – $700 (I won’t recommend a third assessment – the figures are getting worse [biggrin]) – the questions become – is this manageable for you (no answer necessary)? Is the property going to perform long term? If you sold and realised any gains, can you use these funds for better purposes?
I suggest, if you haven’t already, you work out your investment plan and then see if the property will help or hinder your movement towards the end point.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi all,
Another way of considering the ‘four quarters’ from this mornings SMH.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Act now to avoid sorrow tomorrow
June 5, 2004When it comes to retirement planning, too many of us delay. Here’s a spur: the ‘life as a week’ analogy. Simon Hoyle reports.
It’s been said that “tomorrow” is one of the greatest labour-saving devices invented. Unfortunately, it’s also one of the most common wreckers of financial security. Procrastination is the arch enemy of the successful investor.
If someone asked you what you’d be doing when you turned 60, you might be able to answer in a general way. You might be expecting to retire, or preparing to retire. You should have paid off the mortgage; the kids should be well established in their careers and lives. But for too many of us it’s difficult to be too specific.
If someone asked you what you were doing next weekend, you could probably answer confidently. You might already have it sorted: a weekend in the Hunter Valley, perhaps, or watching the Swans, or going out to dinner, seeing a movie, taking the kids out . .
One thing you’d probably want to avoid would be working for some or all of your weekend.
Now imagine that your life could be compressed into a single week, where one day represented 10 years. You’d be 10 on Monday morning, and hit your 30s by Wednesday. By the end of the working week, you’d be well into your 50s.
Advertisement AdvertisementYou’d reach 60, and possibly retirement, on Saturday.
Looked at this way, planning for your retirement would be just like planning for the weekend. And just like your weekend, you would probably prefer to avoid having to work through it. In fact, most of us would prefer to retire early – to knock off at Friday lunchtime.
Paul Gordon, national strategy manager for corporate relations at ipac Securities, uses a “your life as a week” analogy to help people focus on events that may seem a long way off. He says it’s a useful way of making people realise that while retirement may seem ages away, it’s not, and you could make effective plans for it today.
Gordon says he asks people to write the days of the week on a page, with each day representing a decade in their life, starting with Monday. This covers your late primary and secondary schooling years, Tuesday your early years in the workforce, and the weekend of Saturday and Sunday represents your retirement.
He says that when people realise how close they’re getting to their “weekend”, they begin to realise how little time they have to get their finances into gear if they want to retire by 60.
Gordon says the situation with retirement planning is “like your working life – if you don’t do as much as you would have liked in the first two or three days, then it makes for a mad dash if you want to meet a Friday afternoon deadline”. It could even mean you end up working on Saturday, he says.
Gordon says that just as the working week tends to get better as you get closer to Friday, there are also some financial pluses as you get older, including higher income and fewer financial commitments.
But as we all know, we’re generally living longer. That’s like having a long weekend, Gordon says. But it means that planning for the weekend is “even more important, as there is nothing worse than a wasted long weekend”.
Comparing your retirement planning with planning for a weekend helps defeat the investor’s greatest enemy: putting off until tomorrow what they could more productively do today.
Unfortunately, Gordon says, too many leave planning for the weekend until Friday afternoon.
“It becomes a train crash,” he says. “It’s like any other behaviour … I’ve always wanted to lose weight; I’ve always wanted to give up sugar; I’ve always wanted to stop smoking. You have to want to change your behaviour.”
The executive chairman of ipac, Arun Abey, says many people find the idea of retirement planning daunting. They think a plan has to be highly prescriptive and can be severely limiting, and that formulating and sticking to a plan can be difficult.
A good plan should be none of those things, Abey says. A good plan is more like a framework, which enables you to understand how a decision made today affects decisions you’ll face later.
But most importantly, a plan is something that you can put into effect right away. A first step could be as simple as setting up a regular direct debit from a bank account and sweeping a relatively small sum of money – perhaps a few hundred dollars a month – into a special-purpose account. It takes little effort to set it up – you can do it online in some cases – and once it’s set, you can forget about it.
“The reason most people fail or don’t prepare for their ‘weekend’ all that well isn’t because the vast majority of people don’t have the money or resources, it’s procrastination,” Abey says.
“If you have done nothing in the previous five or six days, it probably does become a bit daunting.”
If you know what you need to do on each day of the week to make sure you have a relaxing and enjoyable weekend, the task isn’t nearly as daunting as if you leave the planning until Friday afternoon.
Gordon says he’s found those who are least prepared for the weekend are (usually) male executives, who may be earning good money but aren’t necessarily saving much for retirement.
“We find the audience that needs the greatest education is the Wednesday/Thursday executives who are packaged up and are asked to work 12, 14 hours a day,” Gordon says.
“They have no time for their children, no time for their family, because they are so busy.
“What we try and do is shock them, a little bit, into thinking [about] what they are doing this for, and are they prepared for a train crash.”
The earlier you start planning, the less stressful it is, and the smaller the steps you need to take at each stage to get things properly organised.
“I’m surprised it’s taken us so long to work it out,” Abey says.
“By leaving it until Thursday or Friday, they have missed three or four days of the week – but the key message is that there’s still a lot that they can do, just by facing up to it and choosing to deal with it.
“What is surprising in the Thursday group is not the absence of any sort of structure or plan so much as how much money is frittered away.”
Planning is relevant even for people still at the start of the week, Gordon says, because learning good money habits can never start early enough.
Abey says there are two good reasons why sooner is better for retirement planning. One is that the sooner you start, the less you have to do in a hurry.
And the second is straightforward maths: the power of compound interest.
“Compound interest is powerful if you have the time to compound,” he says. “Otherwise it just becomes simple interest.”
Gordon says investors may not see immediate results, and they do need patience.
“Most people want instant results,” he says.
“Most people want instant success. But it’s a bit like losing weight: if you start to lose weight, you get motivated. If you don’t lose weight, you go off the plan.”
Originally posted by Myydral:Much to my surprise, I have found that my IP is negatively geared. Looking at the raw figures, the deal seems good. But when all expenses are taken into consideration, the goodness fades very quickly. This is not what I intended. I have a couple of questions regarding this.
Without casting aspersions or arrows at Jaffa’s calculator I suggest a second check (Ez-Rent also has a calculator) and balance be done to ensure the new calculations are right. Either way you move (sell or keep) the decisions are significant and as such a second opinion is warranted.
1 – How will this effect my taxes etc ( $532 loss per year ) considering I was under the impression previously that it was positive when I completed my tax returns.
You are not too badly off here. Don’t forget the $500 loss is reduced somewhat by some reimbursement from the ATO.
If you have previously overdeclared income as part of the PAYG 15.15 section adjustment then the ATO will make a correction when your end of year return comes in. Overdeclaring projected income and underdeclaring projected expenses will give you some leeway at the end of the financial year. Doing the opposite is another matter.
2 – The loan is for 62K, valued at 85K. Would I be better off selling the IP and looking for a +ve cashflow one?
Ultimately the course of action you take is best determined by you revisiting why you bought the proeprty in the first place and whether or not it will do what it is designed to do over the long term.
For me a ‘$500’ loss is inconsequential if the property is growing more than that – having said that I would want a lot more growth than $500/annum too.
Everything bar new flooring has been done to the unit. The rent is on market rate. As far as my knowledge goes, no further value can be added.
The thing that kills it is the body corp fees per year – $1600.
If I sold, I’d get approx 22K, but to release equity up to 80%, only 8K.
Don’t forget to factor any CGT liability into your calculations. If you have held the property for 12 months or less then you will incur CG on 100% of the gain.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Jars,
Of course the possibility of looking for cashflow positive properties is an option, however I would be concerned the holiday home will become a large millstone and detract your from your journey for an extended period of time.
Given the desire to periodically ‘put your feet up’ from time to time you may be better ‘paying yourself’ to go on a regular weekend away to recharge the batteries.
According to my calculations the ‘annual loss’ on this property is extremely high and as such you could earmark 10-20% of the otherwise loss money towards funding your regular little ‘breaks’ and at different localities.
But then I am not in your shoes so ………….
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Ted,
And that is when I want to be a fly on the wall.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Jars,
It seems to me that you have drifted off course.
Your other properties seem to be ‘solid investments’ in your situation and have all been purchased with a clearly defined criteria and purpose in mind.
And then came the ‘holiday rental.’
I must admit I am anti-holiday rentals as a rule of thumb and as such I tend to put them almost in the same category as ‘doodads’ and trinkets. Compounding this is the fact that this property has consumed so much of your serviceability and equity for very little return. Any growth will need to be truly significant to offset the negative cashflow you have.
For mine – I think I would be cutting my ‘losses’ and selling the holdiay rental and using the borrowing capacity to get myself back on track. Sure you’ll take a buying and selling loss but it also means you will be back on track.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Russnkez,
Suggest you do a search on richmastery.
Left hand side, click on ‘forum boards’ then click on ‘search’ then enter ‘rich mastery’ in the text box and you’ll see the topic has been discussed at length before.
I am sure there are some very comprehensive comments contained within your search results.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Kay,
I agree with you – what really interests me is……
Valuer A – How did you come up with your figure?
Valuer B – How did you come up with your figure?And the answers from both valuers will go something along the lines of.
Well your honour I did a search of comparable sales in the area and found these properties, rang local real estate agents to see what recent sales evidence I could use, did an inspection of the display unit and analysed the plans and came up with a valuation of $X – I Stand by that figure your honour.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Anna,
Know any painters? They sometimes have a ‘stash’ from completed jobs out the back somewhere.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi George,
The only thing that I can guarantee is that 2015 will be different – how?
Just dusting off the ‘crystal ball’ now and finding the ‘thinking hat’ and what do I see.
1. Continuing seachange drift.
2. Urban sprawl being halted/slowed and ‘infill’ becoming even more prominent.
3. Continued expansion of ‘work from home’ policies.
4. O/seas migration increasing to offset the aging workforce.
5. Australia economy moving even further away from manufacturing base.
6. Increased development of ‘creative’ financial packages by lenders.
7. More and more people using the equity in their own homes as base for other investments
8. ++++++Ultimately I suspect property will continue to be a sound investment through the next 12 (or so) years – after all it was only 12/14 years ago people were saying that it was getting too expensive and repayments were a too large chunk out of the weekly pay packet.
Go even further back and there have always been times when property ‘wasn’t considered a good investment’ but as we know it has been a long term ‘success’
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi all,
Before we get too excited it may be necessary to do some maths. Buying an $150K investment property after 1st July will only save $230.
Also bear in mind the depreciation ‘rules’ change after July 1 so any savings made will be offset with reduced depreciation claims.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Miracle,
My recollection of Display Homes is the same as Yack’s they are usually on one of the main entry point into the new estate and as such will always suffer from ‘noise’ issues.
The few I have looked into seemed a little overpriced and as such I figured that I was going to be paying for the good returns too.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi All,
Whether people believe ‘this time’ will be any different to previous cycles only the individual concerned can make that decision.
But if one truly believes the same factors are playing in this cycle then I believe they are sadly mistaken.
The last and most recent crash (if that is the right description as not all cities were affected the same) was in the early 90’s and this is reflected in the Navra graph. The Australian economy has undergone significant changes (whether you consider them to be pos or neg is up to you) in the past 20 years.
Off the top of my head I offer the floating of the Aus$, the removal of trade barriers, deregulation of the banking industry, changes to retirement ages, introduction of compulsory superannuation, Keating’s macro & micro economic reforms, change in status of the Reserve Bank, increased migration, urbanisation of the Australian population, changing household demographics as examples of some of the more significant changes to our economy that were not present in previous cycles.
I have collated three graphs and tables (Sydney & Melb 1960-90, other cap cities up to 90’s & int rates/loans/values comps 84-92) from three of Jan Somers books for interested people, some of which go back as far as 1960. These graphs predate the Navra information.
I haven’t worked out how to attach files here so people will have to PM me their email address if they want the information.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Shane,
Try this https://www.propertyinvesting.com/forum/topic/10827.html
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.
Hi Redwing,
The comments made by the real estate agent re FHOB mirrors my undertanding and knowlegde. SOmeone I know picked up a house at a reduced price because the FHOB have temporarily left the market. He paid more in stamp duty but made saving on the purchase price.
Derek
derekjones1@bigpond.comProperty Investment Support Available. Ongoing and never stopping. PM welcome.