Forum Replies Created

Viewing 20 posts - 61 through 80 (of 88 total)
  • Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day NishuG,

    Nunawading has had some inmpressive capital gain/growth over the last 3 or 4 years. If you are after capital gain then you could do much worse… However, you will find it difficult to find positively geared properties.

    There are parts of Nunawading that are “less desirable” than others. May I suggest that the Forest Hill side of the train line ( between the train line and Canterbury Road ) is “better” than the East Doncaster side.

    My wife and I bought a unit in Forest Hill/ Nunawading in June last year, and have had easily 12% growth since then.

    Sorry, I can’t comment on the other suburbs you’ve mentioned, but this link may help…

    http://www.homepriceguide.com.au/snapshot/price/index.cfm?action=view

    Just type in the suburb name or postcode, and it will give you the capital growth over the last 12 months.

    Have a good one,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Amni23,

    Hmmmm – how about making a “Reality List” as well as a “Wish List”, compare the two, then meet in the middle…..

    But I think that you know what I mean.

    Or, alternatively, you could just move to somewhere near Port Douglas in QLD, and lie on the beach for a while. It’s very nice up there…

    Either way, I’m sure you’ll have fun !

    [8D]
    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Amni23,

    It sounds like you are looking to buy a principal place of residence – ie somewhere for you to actually live, as opposed to buying an investment property…..

    Might I be so bold as to suggest that you buy with your heart.

    If Carnegie does it for you – buy something in Carnegie !! If an “outer” suburb gives you what you want, then buy there !!

    Make yourself a “wish list” – eg how many bedrooms/bathrooms/big backyard for the dog/near a park for the kids/within 10 minutes walk to the train station/how much can you afford/brick/weatherboard/etc. Then find it, then buy it ! You have to live there, so buy something that you want to live in, in a suburb that you want to live in, based on your “wish list”. You will probably live there for many years, so buy something that you actually want to live in, rather than chasing returns or growth or other intangibles.

    Investment properties must be bought with your head only – the heart should have nothing to do with it at all.

    Good luck

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day all from BDM,

    In real life, my name is Matt. I’m almost 34 and my wife Robyn and I have 1.7 children – a beautiful little 2 1/2 yo daughter Kathleen, and another ( currently known as B2 ) due in August.

    We own our ppor in Mt Waverley, Melbourne, and 2 IPs – both in Melb. We plan to buy at least one IP every even numbered year for the next 4 years, then at least one every year for the following 6 years. Like MiniMogul, the slow / steady / low risk buy and hold option suits us in our current family situation.

    When I grew up I was going to be a wealthy rock star, however I discovered just before the children began to arrive that global domination through property acquisition might be a little easier. I am fortunate in that I have two excellent financial role models – my father and my uncle – who have achieved financial success and now spend much of their time in France or Italy drinking red wine and eating cheese with their friends. Do you hear that creaking sound ? That is my older relatives arteries hardening as they consume alcohol and dairy products….

    Even with “only” 3 properties, I am beginning to see that the income that 2 of these properties produce is already starting to give us more options for our future. Our goal of “providing options” for both us and our children is the driving force behind our investing in property. While I work at a large bank as an IT type computer person, the option of not working is very appealing. Our 12 year plan is to create enough income through our buy and hold property strategy to then begin hardening my own arteries like my parents before me….

    BDM ( Big Daddy Matt )

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Fullout,

    Unfortunately, I cannot answer your question about these country areas either. But if you crunch the numbers and they work for you, then go for it.

    To me, my definition of wealth is “where income exceeds all possible expenses”.

    If this is achieved by multiples of $30 per week – then great.

    If this is achieved by capital gains, then also great.

    Work out what is best for you, then go out of your way to make it happen :-)

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Bruce,

    I have to agree with Mmmay1, in that there is currently a feel and a reality of “oversupply” of brand new inner city CBD (including the Docklands area) apartments here in Melbourne. I would recommend that while you do not totally write off the idea, it would well be worth proceeding with extreme caution before making a final decision.

    I guess it also depends on what your goals are – if you are purely after capital gains/growth, then you might want to check out some inner suburbs such as Richmond, Carlton, St Kilda, Clifton Hill, rather than the CBD ( and most notably the new Docklands developments) itself. Please note that these and most inner suburbs while showing excellent capital growth, will be very negative from a cash flow point of view.

    Some hand links that you might like to explore :
    ( Sooshie – if you read this, please feel free to add them to your “list” if they aren’t already there )

    For Aution results in Melbourne (and around Australia)
    http://www.domain.com.au/UserServices/searchAPM.aspx?mode=auct

    For median prices, and recent growth rates
    http://www.homepriceguide.com.au/snapshot/price/index.cfm?action=view

    For “where on earth is that ? “
    http://www.whereis.com.au

    I hope this helps,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Rick,

    These are my suggestions only – feel free to agree or disagree !!

    1. Crunch some numbers and decide for yourself what you think it is worth. You need to know your “maximum price” before you begin to negotiate. This is the most important step of all.

    2. If by your figures you think that it is worth $230 K ( ie substantially more than their suggested price range using your example of $130 k – $150 K), then offer $149 K immediately !!

    3. If their suggested price range is perhaps a little more than you think the place is worth, ask the owners or the agent “what they will ACCEPT for it”.
    The agent/owner will say “they WANT $x “.
    You then say ” That’s all well and good, but I didn’t ask what they WANT – I asked what they will ACCEPT.” You might be surprised by the answer.

    4. If the agent / owner become difficult or unrealistic, and you are confident with the numbers you have crunched at Step 1 above, then offer less than your “maximum price”. If the negotiations reach your “maximum price” then simply walk away, and go on to the next property.

    I hope this helps,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Andrew,

    Bummer about the “eviction notice” – it makes life suddenly a bit complicated…

    However, it has obviously got you thinking about the future, so that may well be a blessing in disguise.

    Based on the info you have provided, I would suggest a little of option 1 and a little of option 2.

    50 days is, in my humble opinion, not really enough time to decide on life goals, move the family to a new residence, investigate suburbs for potential, inspect houses, crunch the numbers ( due diligence ), let alone find the dream home, buy it and settle, etc.

    I would suggest you rent another place local to where you are now, but make a very firm and very strong commitment to buy a principal place of residence within the next 12 months – whether this is a “house and land” package or not is up to you.

    I would also suggest that you make a commitment to decide with your family what your long term goals are – be that a humble home owner, or have 5 investment properties in 15 years time, or 50 IPs in 5 years time, or some form of world domination through property aquisition….

    Once your goals are in place, and you have a “place of your own” you will most probably find all kinds of doors open up for you.

    Good luck with what ever you decide !!

    Thanks,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Bluebear,

    You are correct with the concept of using the equity to buy more properties until you have “enough properties”.

    Then, instead of buying more, you either sell one or two to pay off most of your debt, or refinance to again eliminate debt. This process may take a few years if done conservatively.

    Once this is all done, you live off the rental income from your remaining ( debt free or almost debt free ) properties, get on a plane, and make it your quest to drink at least one local beer in every country in the world.

    And everyone will be happy.

    Hope this helps,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day,

    How about :

    1. ” Rich is in the eye of the beholder “
    or ” Wealth is in the eye of the beholder “

    2. ” Wealthy ? It’s Easy ! “

    3. ” Get up and get wealthy “

    4. ” Retire Sooner and Wealthier- With Positive Cashflow Property “

    5. ” Think Positive Thoughts “

    Thanks,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Gazza17,

    A possible answer to your question is another few questions :

    What can this adviser person do that you cannot do for yourself ?

    Why do you think that this person will do better things with your money than you can ?

    Have you investigated the validity of what you have been told ” ie done your own “independent research” or due diligence ?

    If you can honestly say that you have done far too much research about similar properties in similar areas, spoken to banks, real estate agents, local councils, surfed the web, and have come to the conclusion that this adviser is correct – then go for it.

    Mind you, if you have done this due diligence, can you get a better deal on your own, rather than through the adviser ?

    If not, then as everyone who has answered you so far have recommended – maybe you should before you go ahead.

    I hope what ever you decide works well for you !

    Thanks,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day,

    Like Brett, I also work in an IT role with one of the “big 4” banks. Part of my role includes the IT support of the network of Financial Planners attached to the bank.

    The “plans” produced by the software ( used by these Finacial Planners ) is also mostly “templates” as Brett mentioned. However, the software takes this concept one step further. Based on the results of some simple “risk analysis” questions ( about 10 questions ), the software also selects the pre-determined funds to invest in !! Also, the way it calculates the amount of “available” cash you have, is based purely on the amount of equity you have in your PPOR ( principle place of residence ).

    End of story. No individual tailoring, no assesing whether you can actually afford the repayments – purely pre-programmed outcomes. Frightening.

    Having said that, there are a handful of Financial Planners attached to the bank who actually do go out of their way to genuinely create a real plan for their clients, but this would literally be less than 5% of the entire financial planning staff. There are very helpful planners out there – but they are rare.

    Like Brett, I too have had some very interesting discussions about money and planning, investing for the futer in both shares and property etc. But it is scary to think that of the BILLIONS of dollars that these planners have under management, most is there because “the computer said so”.

    If you do see a planner – ask heaps and heaps of questions before giving them your money !!

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    Dear 4walls,

    I think that there may be a small but important mathematical oversight in your calculations…

    Try this :

    $80 pw x 12 months ( ie 52 weeks ) x 145 properties = 80 x 52 x 145 = 603200.

    Use the $603200 figure and see what you come up with…..

    I find my calculator a little bit of a challenge too early in the week.

    I hope this helps :-)

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day

    Matt – good idea about the “testimonials” in theory.

    In practice, my wife and I sold our PPOR about 2 years ago, and we were impressed with the testimonials that the agent we eventually went with showed us before we signed up for his services.

    Once the house had sold ( and in the agents defence, he did get us a good price ) I was very surprised when he actually asked us to write a testimonial for him. When we suggested that surely these should be unsolicited, he wrote one himself, and then asked us to sign it for him !!

    Just sharing an experience – I fully agree with your other suggestions for Young Gun. I don’t mean to rain on your parade, so please don’t take offence :-)

    Thanks,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Emma,

    The answer to your question can be another question – ” How long is a piece of string ? “

    What I mean is that what is good for you may not be good for someone else, and vice versa.

    My suggestion is do some serious number crunching.

    How much will it cost to buy in your preferred area of Syd ? What are the capital gains prospects of Syd ? How much value do you personally put on “owning a house of your own” to live in ? What are the costs associated with your preferred area of QLD ? Realistic potential rental income, capital gains, management costs, etc for a property in QLD ? Will it cost more to rent in Syd and buy in QLD, or just to buy in Syd ? What would you / could you do with the dollar difference if you choose the cheaper option? What are your goals ? What are your boyfriends goals ?

    By answering the above questions, you will find more questions that will also need answering….

    Only you can decide which is best for your situation. Maybe try a search on this ( and other ) forums along the lines of “renting vs buying” ?

    I hope this helps !

    BDM

    P.S. Hint : The piece of string mentioned above can be any length you want it to be.

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Rob,

    My simple suggestion is to replace all the power points and light switches with new ones.

    You don’t have to buy fancy ones – just cheapies at the local hardware shop is enough.

    A coat of paint and new power points and light swtiches can make an old place look so much better very quickly and cheaply – thus increasing both desirablilty and rental income.

    I hope this helps,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day everyone,

    I work in the IT section of a major bank. Part of my role is to help fix the problems that the financial planners have with their software / computers. I speak to at least 5 planners ( and usually more ) across Australia every day.

    As a result, I have come to a similar conclusion the Steven Parker mentioned in his comments above.
    In general, they know a fair bit about the regulations of what a financial planner can and cannot do, but they know very little, if anything, about making money.

    Many of them cannot even do their job without the fancy software – they follow the “bouncing ball”, but if the ball stops bouncing, they have absolutely no idea ! I have a copy of the latest and greatest financial planning software on my machine at work, and I fed in my details at one end, and a “plan” came out the other. Scary.

    Maybe I should offer “cheap” financial advice ?!? I have the bouncing ball software, but as I am not trained in financial planning, I cannot interperet the results !! [;)] The “plans” actually do recommend to buy this, and this, and that, based on the input. Biased ? You be the judge. ( In case you are wondering, the answer to the biased question is YES ).

    Mind you, there are exceptions. There are one or two planners who are actually worth their weight in gold, but they are a rarity.

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    Hi there,

    I think what I enjoy and gain encouragement from is the positive attitude ( no pun intended! ) and enthusiasm from the participants of this forum.

    Mind you, there is nothing like the subjects of politics, religion or money to start up a lively discussion.

    Tails277 and Kirby319 have raised some issues that are obviously of concern to them. And fair enough. Roofarmer, Steve, Dan260 and AD have tried to suggest ways to make null and void those concerns. Also fair enough.

    I am a firm believer in the power of the investment vehicle known as property. Other people I know are into shares, or managed funds, or fixed interest, or superannuation, and some others I know still believe that the government will provide for them so they don’t feel they need to invest at all……

    The point that I’m trying to make is – each to their own. As with politics, religion and money, people in each camp will have a million reasons why they are right and everyone else is wrong.

    Tails277 has mentioned several reasons against investing in property – war, increasing interest rates, tenants from hell, etc. Personally, I think that while George W Bush is president of USA, Australian residential property is about the safest investment there is in the world ( although probably residential property in New Zealand as well ), for exactly the same reasons Tails227 thinks it may not be.

    What I find interesting is on another post is the story to Tails227’s Uncle, and on this post the brief mention of Tails227’s father. I am also in the fortunate position where both my father and my uncle retired in their mid-late 40’s with similar incomes/investment portfolios to Tails227’s family, and thus I, like Tails227, have got two excellent role models in my immediate family.

    My only suggestion at this point to Tails227 and Kirby319, is that there is much more to property investment than the 11 second rule, which seems to be the subject of much discussion across this entire forum. The 11 second rule is a great place to start, but it is not the only thing to consider when potentially purchasing a property.

    Once again, each to their own. Dan260 says it best with his comments about life being risky. However, with risk comes reward. No-one is going to hand big piles of cash to us on a silver platter, so therefore if we want the reward we have to work for it and take some risk. The trick is to minimise the risk, and maximise the reward. That is also what I enjoy about this forun – sharing hints and tips on minimising the risk and maximising the reward. I too, like Dan260, have realised that if I don’t do something now, then the future looks scary.

    Tails227 – if you get the chance, I’d love to hear the story of your father. Your uncles story has certainly inspired me !

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day Karen,

    From what you’ve written, it seems your situation is similar to mine in regards to loans – in a structure and security sense, and quantities thereof.

    My wife and I had an investment property with quite a bit of equity in it. This enabled us to borrow against it in order to buy another investment property, thus ensuring our house where we live is kept out of the equation. Thus we have 2 loans – one secured by our house, and another secured by two investment properties. These two loans are quite separate, and independant of each other.

    For what it’s worth, our plan is this :

    Once there is enough equity in both investments properties to satisfy the bank, then we will split the investment loan – create two new loans, each secured by one investment property, again being independant of each other. This will allow us to “double” our chances of refinancing again to release some equity for yet another deposit on another property…. It also allow us to even remove the oldest property from the loan altogether – effectively paying it out ( and formally getting the title in our hot little hands ). From then on, no-one can take it away from us no matter what happens.

    This new property will again be lumped in with the one used to fund the deposit, thus again having a single loan secured by two properties.

    Then we go again, repeating the above process…
    One loan with two properties involved, wait a while, then split to two loans for two properties.

    This, to me anyway, seems to be a “get rich slowly” type plan. It also seems, again to me anyway, to be a “very low risk” plan. There are “faster” methods of course, and many of them are mentioned on this forum. But with my current family situation ( 2yo daughter, another on the way, only one income for a while yet ), I am not prepared to take very much risk at this stage.

    As I mentioned earlier, this is my plan. Other peoples plans will be different….

    I hope this helps,

    BDM

    Profile photo of BDMBDM
    Participant
    @bdm
    Join Date: 2002
    Post Count: 93

    G’day MJ,

    There is a school of thought, here in Melbourne anyway ( and as far as I am aware in Sydney also ), that suggests ground floor units/flats have a lower value than those on upper floors. This is mainly because ground floor units are easier to break into from a crime point of view.

    Whether this is true or not is another story, but perception is a powerful thing.

    Topnotch is also correct with the “eye of the beholder” concept.

    Each to their own – if your investigations suggest that crime is not an issue, nor is the “no view” idea, and you can’t find any other negatives, then see what you can negotiate !

    Thanks,

    BDM

Viewing 20 posts - 61 through 80 (of 88 total)