I am looking at my very first investment and I am in the process of finalising what my buying power is, and getting a pre-approved loan.
With a little help from family it looks as though we could borrow about $250-$280k without LMI. We would ideally like to buy in Melbourne as we plan to add some value by doing some very light cosmetic renovations.
My question to the Steve McKnight world: is it smart to invest in an apartment? I realise this depends on many different factors however most houses are not in our price range, and our budget is very limited. Is an apartment a good foot in the door?
Well .. an apartment has reduced costs on the maintainence front .. due to the fact .. you dont have a garden or surrounds to deal with. It doesnt have the land component for real long term extended growth .. but land growth is not always a given on an investment.
What will work for an apartment investment is an apartment with relatively low ongoing maintainence .. minimal extended features such as pool or shared garden or gymnasium add to all the extra maintainence costs.
Also relatively affordable rates and water bills (depending on state). Rates can get out of hand when the community is sparse or decreasing as the council raises rates to cover costs with a smaller population.
It must also provide a niche market in the area and that must be close to matching demand. An apartment is in the lower formats for liveability and purchase, so there will usually be other choices in the market to take advantage of in poorer times.
Make sure your apartment is in a position where its distances to conveniences are attractive .. and it will be attractive to most renters in the area. Dont sit back and assume that just because its BEEN attractive .. that it will remain attractive in the next decade or so. Apartments .. being the low end .. are the most fussy category for fashion and utility.
The one great thing about apartments is actually their overall .. low footprint. You arent renting out much space .. to get back a decent return. And because land tax is shared amongst the block .. your taxable land component is also minimal.
Apartments have always been a good starting block .. and you must recognise them as such.
Are you sure you want to reduce LMI as it is a deductible expense.
Personally I would increase the loan amount and use the additional funds to either invest again it or cover a basic internal Reno. There is one lender that provides additional funds at settlement which can be used for renovation or even for deposit on your next IP.
As for whether you should buy an apartment this will depend on a number of aspects but as long as the Body Corporate expenses are not too expensive and the property is in a good location wouldn’t have a problem.
Sometimes it is a matter of getting on board and building your portfolio from there.
Cheers
Yours in Finance
Richard Taylor | Australia's leading private lender
Richard, I had no idea that LMI is deductible! I always thought that you can only borrow against the value of the house and not increase a loan to cover things like renovations. Would you be able to let me know what this lender is?
You didn’t state how much you had in total to spend? e.g. $350K – $400K.
It is pretty hard to buy anything decent in Melbourne under $400K unless you are a long way out. You need to be mindful that the further out you go the harder it can be to rent as demand is much weaker as less infrastructure , transport , employment etc.
Let me know some specifics and may be able to help you. All the best of luck.
Regards,
Ian
This reply was modified 10 years, 2 months ago by Ian Finney.
You should be able to buy an apartment in that range but do not buy off the plan and stay out of the CBD. The only thing you will buy off the plan at this range will be small or student apartments. Do not touch them. Look for older apartments as to where to can add value. There is nothing wrong with apartments as an investment. But you need to do your due diligence carefully.
First pick out an area and then get to know it like the back of your hand.
Go through all open for inspections during the weekend and drive by the others
Also inspect rental opens that will give you a good idea of returns
Once you have done this over a few weeks you will get a good idea as to the values in the area and with that knowledge it will help you to know when you have found a great buy
Richard, I had no idea that LMI is deductible! I always thought that you can only borrow against the value of the house and not increase a loan to cover things like renovations. Would you be able to let me know what this lender is?
Hiya
Most lenders will allow an equity release for renos – especially if it’s non structural.
Jaryd be sure to have a strong look over the strata details. Some apartment blocks have run-away strata fees which keep rapidly rising, eating away any profit. Naturally these usually are complexes with gyms, pools, spas etc.
I’ve seen apartments advertised as 7% yields, only to decrease to 3.54% after all costs are taken into consideration.
I was attracted to this site through a facebook ad for Mark Rolton which I have serious misgivings about but that’s another story. A bit of background, im an ex bank employee and ran one of the Big 4s credit operations in Sydney before moving into mortgage broking and am also a qualified financial planner, ive spent all my working career in finance which is just about 20 years.
The short answer to your question Jaryd is – Yes apartments are a sound investment. Though there are many things you need to consider in terms of your personal circumstances and what you hope to achieve medium to long term. Property or any investment should not be considered a short term investment in my view. The mantra here is Time in the market, not timing the market.
Couple of quick ones Richard is correct LMI is tax deductible over 5 years in equal instalments. Why is that important, well if your looking at neg gearing the higher the borrowings the better the tax deduction available though I recommend a max 90% lvr as LMI premiums are ok at that level, above 90% and you paying greater than 2% in LMI which can become exhorbitant in my view. Plus it also gives plenty of options on a lender front
Ians comment rings true, however the main reason you don’t want to be too far from a CBD is the reduced appreciation rate of the property. As it is your first investment I would assume your looking for it to appreciate in value as quickly as possible and the further your away from the city the more likely the growth takes longer. Sure there are exceptions to this but from a safety perspective the closer you are the more saleable a property will be in the future.
Nigel, well im sorry but I totally disagree with your comments, off plan can work no problem, and there are massive advantages, not limited too tax and depreciation savings, but predominantly due to the rent you can command and the quality of tenant, “A GRADE” tenants are what you want and new property gets the pick of these everytime. With any property purchase the research needs to have been done, that is why I recommend a property research house to my clientele, simply these people are professional, have skilled staff who access information that the general public cannot access from sources that most wouldn’t know about. They have key metrics around the state, city, suburb, street and property itself must meet for any buy recommendation, they have a research model that’s independently audited, negotiate price and provide their IP for free but only to clients who are referred to them. They don’t deal with the general public and they are sought for comment in most leading property magazines, tv and radio.
A stat for everyone, Melbourne currently boasts the highest single dwelling household rate in the country at nearly 50%. That’s right approx. 50% of Melbournians reside on their own. Clearly its important to understand market dynamics in an area your considering investing in and unfortunately the public struggle to obtain sufficient info to make informed decisions. Sure people make money out of property or shares everyday, but unless your at the coalface of the industry its very difficult to know exactly whats going on. My analogy here is if im sick I don’t go to the butcher for health advice, I go to the doctor because he is the expert. Investment is no different.
All in all Jaryd my basic advice is this, real estate has 3 interlocking keys, price, type and location. Your price point affects where you can buy and what you can buy which in turn affects the location. You cant buy a 5 bed home in port Melbourne overlooking the bay if your price point is $350k, so what you should do is seek advice from a specialist (just be sure to check their methodology and credentials first). If your ready go for it.
Firstly I am not against buying off the plan but it comes down to due diligence and being very careful with what you buy
These things include looking at the size of the apartment
If they are to small then may have problems with resale
Look at what you are paying. Does the apartment off the plan represent value to what else is on the market
There is a reason the reserve bank are urging caution with investment properties. In the CBD of Melbourne alone there are some 4000 apartments coming out of the ground. Whatever are the tax advantages in new properties goes out the window if the project is to small as you may have difficulty with renting or selling them.
I have been involved in a 17 unit apartment complex in Essendon and most of the sales have been to owner occupiers, so I am not against off the plan or new I just think that you need to due diligence carefully. If you are dealing with a marketing company they will often sell you a property based on what offers them the best commission not what is going to be the best deal for you. Whether new or Established the deal has to work on a number of levels
I agree if buying anything apartment wise or off the plan make sure it is Low to Medium density and has something special or unique about it. Make sure there is some land component in the project. Buy one of fewer apartments, not one of many ie. “less is more” remember “land appreciates buildings depreciate”.